“It puts a big burden on employers”: Businesses face tough choices after Gov. Greg Abbott bans vaccine mandates

Sign up for The Brief, our regular newsletter that keeps readers up to velocity connected the astir indispensable Texas news.

Companies doing concern successful Texas present look caller and analyzable challenges aft Gov. Greg Abbott this week banned COVID-19 vaccine mandates for each entities successful the authorities — including backstage businesses — for employees oregon customers.

The ramifications for businesses could statesman arsenic soon arsenic Friday, erstwhile companies that participate into declaration enactment with the national authorities volition beryllium required to person each employees vaccinated nether orders from the White House.

Ad

This conflicts with Abbott’s prohibition connected vaccine mandates, putting the galore Texas businesses that person national contracts successful a pugnacious position: Comply with national instrumentality and interruption Abbott’s ban, oregon comply with Abbott and crook down concern from the national government.

In summation to national contractors, President Biden has besides announced that businesses with much than 100 employees indispensable mandate vaccination against COVID-19 oregon necessitate regular testing.

For Texas nursing homes, which person struggled during a pandemic that has ravaged their residents and decimated their workforce, a national regularisation announced successful August requires each nursing location employees to beryllium vaccinated successful bid for their facilities to proceed participating successful the Medicare and Medicaid programs. If nursing homes alternatively comply with Abbott’s caller rule, they could suffer captious national money.

Ad

More than 66,000 Texans person died from COVID-19, including 10% of nursing location residents during the archetypal twelvemonth of the virus.

“This harms Texans directly,” Karen Vladeck, an employment lawyer successful Austin, said of the caller bid from Abbott. “I conscionable deliberation it wasn’t good thought out.”

Abbott’s bureau did not reply to a petition for comment.

On apical of prohibiting immoderate entity successful Texas from requiring vaccinations, Abbott's bid besides lists respective expanded exemptions. Vladeck and different employment lawyers said that this adds to the vaccine dilemma facing businesses successful Texas. Under Abbott’s caller rule, radical whitethorn opt retired of a vaccine request for aesculapian reasons, including if they beryllium they person had COVID-19 successful the past, contempt scientists wide agreeing that this does not support radical against contracting the virus.

Ad

“The enforcement order’s aesculapian crushed connection is simply a spot unusual due to the fact that usually you exempt radical for aesculapian reasons if they person a terrible allergic absorption to a vaccine,” said Elizabeth Sepper, a instrumentality prof astatine the University of Texas astatine Austin. Abbott’s bid is “meant to screen radical who don't privation to get the vaccine due to the fact that they believe, rather wrongly, that they're wholly protected by already having COVID.”

Abbott’s regularisation besides allows radical to opt retired of a vaccine request if they beryllium they clasp a heavy idiosyncratic content against getting jabbed.

Any entity that fails to comply with Abbott’s regularisation could person up to a $1,000 fine.

Abbott’s Monday bid is simply a reversal from his presumption successful August, erstwhile the Pfizer vaccine received last support from the U.S. Food and Drug Administration. At the time, Abbott’s spokesperson said that businesses had the enactment of mandating vaccination for employees and "private businesses don't request authorities moving their business."

Ad

“It’s each astir institution prime successful Texas, but present it's travel to thing that they don't similar what the companies are choosing,” Vladeck said. “It puts a large load connected employers.”

Ted Shaw, president of the Texas Hospital Association, said Abbott's determination was political.

"Texas hospitals powerfully reason efforts underway to hamstring them from being capable to necessitate vaccination of their ain staff, galore of whom are astatine the bedside each time with children and adults who are susceptible to COVID-19," Shaw said successful a statement. "This governmental enactment undercuts the cardinal ngo of hospitals, and patients and unit cannot beryllium enactment astatine unnecessary risk. Hospitals person soldiered connected for months astatine crushed zero of this pandemic. As experts successful healing and redeeming lives, hospitals indispensable person the trust, respect and flexibility to mandate vaccines successful their ain facilities to support the radical of Texas.”

White House Press Secretary Jen Psaki besides condemned Abbott's action.

Ad

"I deliberation it's beauteous wide erstwhile you marque a prime that's against each nationalist wellness accusation and information retired there, that it's not based connected what is successful the involvement of the radical you are governing, it's possibly successful the involvement of your ain politics," Psaki said Tuesday.

Ray Perryman, an economist based successful Waco, said Abbott’s determination is unhelpful for the authorities system arsenic it recovers from the economical impacts of the pandemic.

“This bid volition astir surely origin disorder with conflicting requirements for galore businesses,” Perryman said successful an email to the Tribune. “From an economical perspective, it is not indispensable and apt counterproductive.”

Two salient Texas-based companies, American Airlines and Southwest Airlines, already necessitate employees to beryllium vaccinated. Spokespeople for the 2 airlines told the Tribune that request won't alteration contempt Abbott's caller order.

“One of the hallmarks of capitalist system is the quality of the backstage assemblage to marque decisions without authorities involution unless determination is simply a morganatic nationalist interest that needs to beryllium addressed," Perryman said. "It is hard to spot however forcing companies to exposure their employees, vendors, and customers to greater hazard of a deadly illness and fostering the dispersed and mutation of that illness brings a compelling nationalist benefit.”

Ad

Harris County Attorney Christian D. Menefee encouraged Texans to writer Abbott implicit the move.

“The Governor’s latest enforcement bid banning backstage businesses from keeping their employees and customers harmless is shameful,” Menefee said successful a statement. “And we cognize that this is mostly a governmental bluster designed to make disorder and taxable businesses to burdensome lawsuits, which tin lone dilatory down our economical recovery.”

The Greater Houston Partnership, a starring concern radical successful Harris County, besides denounced Abbott’s action.

“The governor’s enforcement bid does not enactment Texas businesses’ quality and work to make a harmless workplace,” Bob Harvey, the group’s president, said successful a written statement. “While the courts volition apt determine the validity of this order, we promote each employers to proceed to beforehand the value of vaccinations with their employees. Vaccinations are our way retired of the pandemic, and the Partnership remains focused connected supporting steps that pb to improving the complaint of vaccination successful our community.”

Ad

Abby Livingston and Karen Brooks Harper contributed reporting.

Disclosure: Greater Houston Partnership, the Texas Hospital Association and the University of Texas astatine Austin person been fiscal supporters of The Texas Tribune, a nonprofit, nonpartisan quality enactment that is funded successful portion by donations from members, foundations and firm sponsors. Financial supporters play nary relation successful the Tribune's journalism. Find a implicit list of them here.